Minutes of the DLS: April 12, 2007

 

Hola, amigos. Word on the street is that this is suicide and depression awareness week. Like last year, they've scheduled it to coincide with our elections. I've been told that this is entirely coincidental. This being the case, I know about suicide and depression awareness week because the guy who does PostSecret came and gave a talk the other night. He said he'd reveal a secret of his own at the end of the talk. For those of you who missed it, he posted the secret to end all secrets. Namely, that he made up all of those postcards. Yep. He even cut out the decorative letters and photos himself. C'mon, folks. Nobody's really that f*cked up. Actually, that's not true. People have been sending me secrets of their own this week. Take this lighthearted example, addressed to yours truly from someone named Wesley Wiggins:

“Hey...do you realize that you are an asshole? You should be ashamed of yourself. You remind me of the jackass that killed all of those people...thoughtless and cruel. What if this picture got out and a poor VT student saw it? How would you feel? You probably wouldn't feel anything because you are a heartless bastard who has no soul. There is a spot reserved for you...in hell. Thanks for your time you jerk.”

Well, shiver me timbers, Batman. I can't say that I disagree with him on the “heartless bastard without a soul” part, and maybe even the “going to hell” part, but gee whillikers, did he have to bring assholes into this? Goodness gracious. Anyway, just thought I would give you a sneak preview of the self-important rambling you'll hear for the next nine hours. Tonight is bound to be thoroughly depressing, but like the secret man said, don't commit suicide. We need quorum.

The meeting of Thursday, the 12th of April 2007 was called to order. Once again, there were no guests present.

There was one petition for membership. Ms. Gonterman catalogued the different types of “crazy,” and was gloriously welcomed into the Society, since we like totally rilly rilly like that Gnarls Barkley song.

Ms. Wilkinson was appointed critic. We had more nominations.

In Committee Reports, Freak and Geek voting is occurring, the graduation ceremony is in doubt, another literary society is visiting over the summer, extracurricular activities of members are being loaded onto the website, the Lost & Found is being emptied, the John Elliot bake sale is happening, and there is to be a camping trip.

In New Business, Mr. Sharp noted that Israel's tactics are polarizing its enemies and creating new types of terror. He rose to present
BIR: The state of Israel should not exist.
Respectfully submitted,
Casey Sharp

Mr. Addison disagreed, bringing up the culture of hate into which Palestinians are socialized. Also, Israel is benevolent compared to the U.S.. He gave his tried and true “butterfly” anecdote.

Ms. Keyes-Blumer argued that the resolution did not discuss what Israel actually is, and that if Israel is taken to mean its post-1967 boundaries, then the resolution should be voted against. As a functioning democracy, Israel should be supported.

` Mr. Pearl brought up the inequality among Jews and non-Jews in Israel. The problem is the Israeli government as it currently exists.

Mr. Vaudo claimed that out of all the minorities ever hated, Jews are hated the most. If you disregard the suicide bombings, Israel is a safe haven.

Mr. Ballard disagreed with the premise that Israel's unjust founding made it an illegitimate state. After all, the U.S. was founded upon similar principles. Also, Israel's existence is useful and beneficial.

Mr. Brettschneider said that Israel is a significant arms distributor, though I'm never quite sure what he's saying when he's up there.

The question was called, and failed 6 to 18 among members. It was noted that Mr. Sharp voted against his resolution. He pulled an Addison, in other words. Mr. Vaudo noted that Mr. Pearl is a bad Jew for voting against the resolution. Mr. Pearl then noted that he isn't actually Jewish.

Mr. O'Brien then rose to present
BIR: All federal funding for developing contraceptives and birth control should be reserved for men until non-surgical, non-barrier methods have been developed for male sexual empowerment.
Respectfully submitted,
Kevin O'Brien

Mr. Hansen disagreed, stating that society needs to put more money into developing new contraceptives for both sexes.

Mr. Pearl reminded the chamber that effective methods of male birth control already exist, like girlfriends' dads with gun collections. He went on to say that the dad won't really know unless she ends up pregnant.

Ms. Bernhard described how society has dictated that the burden of birth control fall on women alone. Since men don't embrace that role, the resolution would not be solvent.

Ms. Keyes-Blumer noted that women's methods of contraception have problems, too, and so more research needs to be done on male methods.

Mr. Addison soliloquized on the many uses of condoms aside from birth control. Also, men won't remember to take a pill.

Ms. Barnett argued that the resolution simply shifts the problem of birth control. More research needs to be done on both women and men.

I advocated more traditional methods of birth control, which could be mechanical or herbal in nature.

Mr. Hill said that more options are always helpful.

The question was called and failed 9 to 12 among members. Our guest voted against it as well.

Mr. Brettschneider then rose to tell us that everything everyone does is the result of greed, presenting
BIR: Greed is good.
Respectfully submitted,
Daniel Brettschneider

Mr. Sharp argued that the resolution attributes everything to a single descriptive category. As such the resolution just plays with words.

Mr. Pearl argued that the resolution defined greed too broadly.

Mr. Williamson clarified that society operates on the fundamental assumption that greed equals good. Indeed, it is the basis of Western political thought.

Mr. Hansen said that desire is a part of greed, but immediate decisions reflect neither desire nor greed. Caring about things is more important than either of those traits.

Mr. Addison argued that we live in a society based on lust, not greed. A desire for one another drives people to seek material gain.

Ms. Herschman noted that greed is not always good.

The question was called and failed 3 to 18 among members. Our guest voted against, as well.

Mr. Williams then rose to present
BIR: The motion picture rating system is not keeping young children away from inappropriate material and should be abolished.
Respectfully submitted,
Patrick Williams

Mr. Dolan responded that the ratings system has some useful qualities.

Ms. Buhlig said that the burden falls on the parents, and that it is not the job of the MPAA to decide.

Mr. Pearl said that the MPAA ratings exist for parents who don't know about the movies.

Ms. Barnett discussed the porn room in her local video store.

Ms. Moxley orated, eloquently and beautifully, about how her parents owned a video store, in which she watched parents check the ratings before renting them.

I made the point that the MPAA ratings are symptomatic of a culture that, instead of raising kids, lets them passively soak entertainment.

Mr. Steinberg recalled inappropriate children's entertainment, noting the nudity on “Sesame Street.” He was summarily ejected.

The question was called, and failed 3 to 14 among members and 1 to 2 among guests.

Mr. Webber then recalled the Red Cross's discrimination against gays as blood donors, presenting
BIR: The Red Cross is a bigoted organization.
Respectfully submitted,
Ryan Webber

Mr. Addison spoke against, arguing that risk factors, including, but not limited to, homosexuality, must be mitigated.

Ms. Moxley recalled that, as a lifeguard, she had to watch a racist Red Cross video, demonstrating the organization's propensity for intercultural callousness.

Ms. Bernhard argued that the policy is bigoted, but the people who receive blood ultimately benefit.

Mr. Vaudo reminded the chamber that the Red Cross tests blood anyway, and thus has no reason to discriminate.

The question was called, and passed 17 to 4 among members and 3 to 0 among guests. Mr. Sharp noted that if we donated trans-substantiated communal wine, then the problem would be solved.

Mr. Vaudo then rose to present
BIR: ___________ should be the new national anthem
Respectfully submitted,
Zak Vaudo

We then heard members advocate the following songs:
Kottonmouth Kings, Milkshake, the French national anthem only better, Courtesy of the Red, White & Blue, We Are The Champions, Old McDonald, Monty Python theme, Imperial March, and Free Bird.

The question was called. Members and guests voted in favor of the French national anthem, only done better. It was noted that the Imperial March is Dick Cheney's ringtone.

Mr. Sharp then rose again to recall the use of the term “chamber” to describe the interior of the Hall. He presented
BIR: Demosthenian Hall is the world's largest bong.
Respectfully submitted,
Casey Sharp

Mr. Addison disagreed. The hall has always been used for illicit activity, but these activities have been undertaken by men of action, a characterization that does not describe pot-smoking hippies.

Mr. Pearl agreed, since alumni like Crawford Long based their careers off of psychoactive substances such as ether.

The question was called, and failed 4 to 14 among members. A guest also voted against. It was noted by Ms. Wilkinson that the Hall is actually the world's largest “hotbox.”

The meeting was adjourned at 11:25 subject to Ms. Wilkinson's critic's report.

Respectfully submitted,
William D. Richards